IPA Newspack
  • Home
  • now
  • politics
  • business
  • markets

IPA /

IPA Special

IPA Special

Year Of Ecstacy And Agony For Libertarians

By K. Raveendran

            2018 will go down in history as a
year in which Indians experienced bouts of ecstasy as well as agony when it
came to intrusion of the state into their private lives. We hardly finished
celebrating the Supreme Court verdict in Aadhaar case, which upheld privacy as
a fundamental right, though with certain riders, drawing strength from the
historical verdict of a 9-member bench pronounced a year earlier, unanimously
declaring that the citizen’s right to privacy was guaranteed by the
Constitution. But as the year wound down to a close, dark clouds hang over the
horizon, threatening to undo whatever we had achieved in the past couple of
years by way of judicial backing for privacy of the individual.

            Years of efforts by privacy
soldiers, judicial work and debate have been brought to naught in one stroke by
the Modi government through its act of bringing a draconian rule through the
back door. The snooping order authorised 10 agencies, including the
Intelligence Bureau, the CBI, the National Investigation Agency, RAW and the
Delhi police, all of which have been abused by the ruling parties as political
tools to hunt down opponents, to intercept, monitor and decrypt any information
generated, transmitted, received or stored in any computer resource in the
country.

            Then comes another ominous report
that the government is considering changes in the IT Act to force internet,
chat and social media companies to trace and identify people using messaging
platforms. It is believed that the move, which was discussed during a meeting
with internet companies and the IT ministry, will impact platforms like
WhatsApp that promise encryption and enhanced privacy to users. These companies
have been resisting attempts by the government to harvest data, but changes to
the IT Act would make it difficult to them to refuse such requests in future.

            The new developments bring the worst
fears that Justice Chandrachud expressed in his dissenting note in the Aadhaar
constitutionality case. Chandrachud had concluded that there was real danger of
India becoming a surveillance state even with the limited privacy breaches for
Aadhaar. He maintained that the government cannot justify the intrusion on
people’s privacy just by insisting that it will be used to provide welfare
services. “Dignity and the rights of individuals cannot be made to depend on
algorithms or probabilities. Constitutional guarantees cannot be subject to the
vicissitudes of technology. Denial of benefits arising out of any social
security scheme which promotes socioeconomic rights of citizens is violative of
human dignity and impermissible under our constitutional scheme,” the lone
dissenting note asserted.

            While Justice Chandrachud was
discussing the threat to privacy in the context of Aadhaar, the new regulations
take this intrusion to much deeper levels. The feared Orwellian state seems to
be already upon us. The government wants to put in place such an oppressive
regime in the defence of national security. National security is, of course, of
paramount importance and a certain amount of surveillance is definitely called
for. But that should not reduce us into a police state where fear of government
drives us to a state of nervous breakdown, as it happened to the American
psyche in the wake of the Homeland Security tyranny. In the aftermath of the
9/11 attacks, successive administrations converted America into a colossal
surveillance state that seeped into the lives of millions of ordinary citizens,
creating an apocalyptic dread. Homeland security measures made life difficult
not only for the Americans, but the rest of the world as well. Finally, the
Americans have realised the folly of living in constant fear and many of those
programmes have been phased out.

            The government’s oppressive
surveillance regime promises a long struggle ahead for those who value personal
liberty and freedoms. But that is no reason to get disconsolate as Indians have
proved time and again that, when challenged, they are capable of taking their
affairs into their own hands. Lord Krishna proclaims in Bhagvad Gita how He
incarnates himself whenever adharma crosses the limit. The Indian voters have
made Bhagvad Gita a living doctrine: Whenever they find government tyranny
crossing all acceptable levels, they have been making effective interventions.
They did it in 2014 and the recent assembly election results provide a trailer
of what is coming up in 2019. Gone are the days when the Indian voter can be
led up the garden path with empty slogans and gimmicks. Today they are a
matured lot, capable of seeing through games played by scheming politicians.

            So it can be safely assumed that the
repressive mechanism being put in place by the Modi government has only limited
life. Two public interest litigations, one by ML Sharma and another by Ami
Sahni, are already before the Supreme Court, which had once warned the
government against any plan to snoop on WhatsApp, email accounts or social
media posts on Facebook, Twitter or Instagram while dealing with a petition
challenging the move to set up a social media monitoring hub, which the
government was forced to drop. The latest PILs accuse the government of
treating every citizen as a criminal, which is the essence of the home ministry
order.

(IPA Service)

The post Year Of Ecstacy And Agony For Libertarians appeared first on Newspack by India Press Agency.

IPA Newspack

IPA Special

NITI Aayog Has Failed To Play Any Effective Role In Planning For Indian Economy

May 30, 2023
IPA Special

Opposition Parties Could Not Meet Properly PM Challenge On New Parliament Building

May 30, 2023
IPA Special

Congress Dithering Over Supporting AAP On Ordinance Is Height Of Stupidity

May 30, 2023
IPA Special

Bengal Congress Making Too Much Noise Over Sole MLA’s Defection To Trinamool

May 30, 2023
IPA Special

An Isolated Imran Khan On No-Fly List Is Not A Bad News For The Captain

May 30, 2023
IPA Special

Massive Outreach Programme By BJP In Uttar Pradesh For 2024 Polls

May 30, 2023
IPA Special

Fresh Manipur Violence Exposes Failure Of Centre And BJP State Govt

May 30, 2023
Happening Now

Cong clinches a Rajasthan peace deal for election

May 30, 2023
Politics

Opposition weighing one man against Modi in 2024

May 30, 2023
Politics

HP-Punjab tussle over power project intensifies

May 30, 2023
Politics

Owaisi says Modi event was like Delhi Sultan coronation

May 30, 2023
Politics

EC orders updating of electoral rolls in five states

May 30, 2023
IPA Special

India’s Triangular Relationship With Russia, China And The US Is Under Pressure

May 29, 2023
IPA Special

New Parliament Symbolises Hindutva’s Aim To Return To Monarchy

May 29, 2023
IPA Special

Rajasthan Politics Turning More Complex Before Assembly Polls

May 29, 2023
IPA Special

NITI Aayog Is Steadily Losing Its Relevance As An Useful Think Tank For Planning

May 29, 2023
IPA Special

Blockchain Is Getting Freed From Cryptocurrency Opening Up New Avenues

May 29, 2023
IPA Special

Remembering The ’Golden’ Days Of Media Persons In Old Parliament Building

May 29, 2023
IPA Special

Cold War-End ‘Peace Dividend’ Set To Go With New ‘War Tax’ After Ukraine War

May 29, 2023
IPA Special

The Curious Story Of Continuous Duel In US Congress Over Debt Ceiling Limit

May 29, 2023

An appeal

The legacy of IPA, founded by Nikhil Chakravartty, the doyen of journalism in India, to keep the flag of independent media flying high, is facing the threat of extinction due to the effect of the Covid pandemic. Only an emergency funding can avert such an eventuality. We appeal to all those who believe in the freedom of expression to contribute to this noble cause.
Click here to learn more

Share

Reply

  • 0
More on IPA

NITI Aayog Has Failed To Play Any Effective Role In Planning For Indian Economy

May 30, 2023 4:24 pm | IPA Staff

By Kalyani Shankar One of the first things Prime Minister Narendra Modi did soon after assuming office nine years ago was dismantling the Planning Commission...

IPA Special

Opposition Parties Could Not Meet Properly PM Challenge On New Parliament Building

May 30, 2023 4:22 pm | IPA Staff

By Sushil Kutty Prime Minister Narendra Modi bounced back from the brink and the opposition parties are together and singly to blame for the comeback....

IPA Special

Congress Dithering Over Supporting AAP On Ordinance Is Height Of Stupidity

May 30, 2023 3:54 pm | IPA Staff

By Dr. Gyan Pathak Penny wise pound foolish, is a well-known adage, applied to someone trying to save a penny while remaining ignorant of greater...

IPA Special

Bengal Congress Making Too Much Noise Over Sole MLA’s Defection To Trinamool

May 30, 2023 3:31 pm | IPA Staff

By Tirthankar Mitra Bairan Biswas, the lone Congress legislator from Sagardighi, Murshidabad, defecting to Trinamool Congress does not send a signal of unity in the...

IPA Special

NITI Aayog Has Failed To Play Any Effective Role In Planning For Indian Economy

in IPA Special
May 30, 2023   ·  

Opposition Parties Could Not Meet Properly PM Challenge On New Parliament Building

in IPA Special
May 30, 2023   ·  

Congress Dithering Over Supporting AAP On Ordinance Is Height Of Stupidity

in IPA Special
May 30, 2023   ·  

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Follow us on
Up Next: Make Right To Health A Fundamental Right
©2020 -2021 India Press Agency, All Rights Reserved.
Newspack by India Press Agency | Statement of Ownership | Contact Us
logo
  • Home
  • now
  • politics
  • business
  • markets