IPA Newspack
  • Home
  • now
  • politics
  • business
  • markets

IPA /

IPA Special

IPA Special

Barely Four Months In Office, Cji Under A Cloud

By
K Raveendran

            The
credibility of the Supreme Court was considered to be at the lowest ebb during
the tenure of chief justice Dipak Misra. The so-called ‘mutiny’ by the four
senior-most judges was described as the darkest hour of Indian judiciary,
amidst allegations of the CJI misusing his Master of the Roster powers to constitute
‘pliable’ benches ready to do the bidding of interested parties, planting
serious doubt in the minds of people about the integrity of the institution.
Justice Misra has even been accused by a retired colleague of having behaved
like an ‘agent’ of some external force, which the judge stopped short of
identifying, but the reference was quite obvious.

            It
was widely believed that when Justice Ranjan Gogoi, who was one of the
participants of the unprecedented press conference called by Justice J Chelameswar,
since retired, as a ‘call of duty to the nation’, took office as the new CJI,
there would be a break from the past and that he would restore the credibility
of the apex court. But that was not to be.

            It
is not even four months since Justice Gogoi took charge, but his tenure is
already dogged by controversies. Gogoi used his ‘power as the chief justice’ to
overturn the decision of the collegium headed by himself to elevate Justice
Rajendra Menon and Justice Pradeep Nandrajog of the Delhi and Rajasthan high
courts respectively to the Supreme Court and instead appointed Justice Dinesh
Maheshwari and Justice Sanjiv Khanna. Justice Maheshwari from the Karnataka
high court is the one against whom Justice Chelameswar had raised serious
allegations.

            It
seems the Chief Justice was miffed by the ‘leak’ of the news of the
appointments of Menon and Nandrajog to the media and apparently the decision is
prompted by ‘additional material’. Justice Gogoi has taken great pains to
explain why he changed the collegium’s decision, but most people in judicial
circles and the public at large refuse to be convinced. In any case, the ‘leak’
has nothing to do with the calibre of the affected judges and as such the
action amounts to punishing them for no fault of theirs, unless the leak itself
can be attributed to them, which does not seem to be the case.

            The
verdict in the Rafale case, in which the court could not differentiate between
the Anil Ambani group and the Mukesh Ambani ‘s original Reliance group, gave a
clumsy picture of the commitment and application of mind of the judges to their
work, apart from questions of judicial propriety in deciding substantive
issues. The excuse of the court having been misled by the government is
untenable as the court is supposed to have a mind of its own, capable of
questioning the veracity of whatever is placed before it. As the judge heading
the bench, the chief justice cannot run away from the blame.

            The
CJI’s performance so far by no means adds up to the expectation and there has
been a big gap between word and the deed. He took office promising to reduce
the huge backlog of cases, the biggest bane of Indian judiciary. Barely three
months before he took over as the new CJI Justice Gogoi had stressed the need
for the judiciary to be more proactive. “Not a reform but a revolution is what
it needs, to be able to meet the challenges on the ground and to keep this
institution serviceable for a common man and relevant for the nation. For the
effectiveness of the judgments to show, the justice dispensation system has to
be made more result oriented i.e. to say, more focused on enforcement,” he had
thundered while delivering the Ramnath Goenka memorial lecture.

            But
there has been no change in the highly bureaucratic approach of the court under
his leadership. His own approach in several instances has been far from being
dynamic and proactive as he left everything to routine, which is what his
predecessors have also been doing. If it has taken three months to decide on a
date to resume hearing on the Ramjanmabhoomi dispute, one can imagine the time
it takes to conclude the arguments and arrive at a decision on such a humongous
case. The ‘routine’ manner in which the reconstitution of the bench to hear the
case has been handled gives an unintended advantage to one of the parties by
default although that may never have been in the court’s mind. This is
certainly not proactive.

            Even
in terms of routine, there has been a certain lack of consistency in the CJI’s
approach. This is particularly true in the case of the knotty Sabarimala case.
The controversial verdict allowing the entry of a restricted category of women
into the hill shrine had produced a deluge of review petitions. When the
petitions came up before a CJI-headed bench just a few days before the
three-month pilgrim season was to begin, the court decided to post the hearing
for January 22. The uncertainty marred the crucial Mandalam-Makaravilakku
pilgrimage, plunging the entire Kerala into turmoil and violence.

            But
when two activists, who entered the temple under the cover of darkness by
disguising their identities with the help of police, approached the same bench
asking for round the clock police protection, it heard the plea on an urgent
basis and ordered the state government to provide such security. It is a
mystery why the women directly approached the Supreme Court and the court
obliged them when they should have actually gone to the Kerala high court,
which already has a specialist bench to hear matters relating to Sabarimala.
The only saving grace is that the Supreme Court saw through the game of the
women, allegedly sponsored by the state government, to use the petition to
force a decision against objections raised in the review petitions. (IPA Service)

The post Barely Four Months In Office, Cji Under A Cloud appeared first on Newspack by India Press Agency.

IPA Newspack

IPA Special

More Russian Oil Is Making Backdoor Entry Into NATO Nations Via Saudi Arabia, UAE

June 5, 2023
IPA Special

Questions Galore About BRS Decision Not To Join Crucial Opposition Conclave

June 5, 2023
IPA Special

Secure Railway System To Prevent Balasore Like Deadly Accidents

June 5, 2023
IPA Special

Opposition Is Looking Confident Of Defeating RSS-BJP Combine In 2024

June 5, 2023
Happening Now

CBI to take over probe into Odisha train tragedy

June 5, 2023
IPA Special

More Jitters For Narendra Modi-Led BJP Before 2024 Polls

June 5, 2023
IPA Special

Uptick In Q4 GDP Growth Is Positive But Challenges Remain In Current Fiscal

June 5, 2023
IPA Special

Bengal BJP In A Quandary Over Holding 1,000 Meetings In Four Months

June 5, 2023
Happening Now

Amit Shah assurance to wrestlers on due course of law

June 5, 2023
Politics

Row over Karnataka minister’s remark on cow slaughter

June 5, 2023
Politics

No intent to address safety lapse: Kharge tells Modi

June 5, 2023
Politics

Modi driving car looking into rearview mirror, says Rahul

June 5, 2023
Politics

Rahul says people of India, and not just Cong, will defeat BJP

June 4, 2023
Politics

Mehbooba gets a passport after three-year wait

June 4, 2023
Politics

Rail minister says no time for politics after spat with Mamata

June 4, 2023
Politics

Sibal cites govt inadequacies behind Odisha rail tragedy

June 4, 2023
Politics

Rare show of appreciation for Modi from Sam Pitroda

June 4, 2023
IPA Special

Nepalese Prime Minister’s Four Day Visit Bring Ties With India Closer

June 3, 2023
IPA Special

What Will Be India’s Response To US’s Bid To Offer NATO+ Membership

June 3, 2023
IPA Special

Narendra Modi Has Been Most Successful In Using Technology For Governance

June 3, 2023

An appeal

The legacy of IPA, founded by Nikhil Chakravartty, the doyen of journalism in India, to keep the flag of independent media flying high, is facing the threat of extinction due to the effect of the Covid pandemic. Only an emergency funding can avert such an eventuality. We appeal to all those who believe in the freedom of expression to contribute to this noble cause.
Click here to learn more

Share

Reply

  • 0
More on IPA

More Russian Oil Is Making Backdoor Entry Into NATO Nations Via Saudi Arabia, UAE

June 5, 2023 3:56 pm | IPA Staff

By Nantoo Banerjee The cat is out of the bag. India is not the only country using imported Russian oil to export processed petro-products. West...

IPA Special

Questions Galore About BRS Decision Not To Join Crucial Opposition Conclave

June 5, 2023 3:46 pm | IPA Staff

By Sushil Kutty Sulking is common to non-BJP Chief Ministers. And opposition unity suffers. Right now the tribe of non-BJP Chief Ministers sees opportunity in...

IPA Special

Secure Railway System To Prevent Balasore Like Deadly Accidents

June 5, 2023 3:33 pm | IPA Staff

By Dr. Gyan Pathak Only few years ago, the Union Minister of Railways had claimed in the Parliament of India that they made railway journey...

IPA Special

Opposition Is Looking Confident Of Defeating RSS-BJP Combine In 2024

June 5, 2023 2:28 pm | IPA Staff

By Arun Srivastava For nine long years, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has been dictating political actions in India, but the expected opposition meet will not...

IPA Special

More Russian Oil Is Making Backdoor Entry Into NATO Nations Via Saudi Arabia, UAE

in IPA Special
Jun 5, 2023   ·  

Questions Galore About BRS Decision Not To Join Crucial Opposition Conclave

in IPA Special
Jun 5, 2023   ·  

Secure Railway System To Prevent Balasore Like Deadly Accidents

in IPA Special
Jun 5, 2023   ·  

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Follow us on
Up Next: Tejashvi’s Lucknow Parleys Upset Congress
©2020 -2021 India Press Agency, All Rights Reserved.
Newspack by India Press Agency | Statement of Ownership | Contact Us
logo
  • Home
  • now
  • politics
  • business
  • markets